A mom told her 13-year-old daughter that she wanted her to attend a week of summer camp before she started high school. Sounds reasonable, right? Not to the girl. The mom’s request unleashed an hour of whining, crying and histrionics, resulting in her backing down. I think this incident points to a lifetime of overprotection, and this family is not alone.
The first half of the 20th century was the golden age of children’s free play. Kids no longer had to work, and schooling was nowhere near as intense as it became later in the century. My peers and I all were able to walk out the door on summer mornings and not return until the dinner bell rang. We were out, playing games in the street and hiking in the woods. Our parents trusted us to take care of ourselves and each other, and we paid back that trust with mostly trustworthy behavior.
Today, adults overprotect children from any possible danger. We seriously underestimate their ability to take care of themselves and make good judgments. That underestimation becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy. By depriving kids of freedom, we deprive them of opportunities to take control of their own behavior and emotions. Free play out in the world gives kids the chance to solve problems, control their impulses, get along with others and manage risk-taking. There is no substitute for play as the means for learning all of these life skills. Research shows children in the U.S. pay less attention to what is going on around them, learning less through observation. Unlike previous generations, kids learn to expect adults to protect them and solve their problems.
Parents have a tendency to view childhood as a time of résumé building rather than a time of play. They have been led to believe that if they push their children, it will ensure them a “successful” future. I think uncertain times like these require more personal responsibility, independent thought, creativity and a willingness to take risks. I fear that our fear-based parenting is not preparing kids adequately for the future. Our children need more time for free play with their friends, exploring nature and taking healthy risks. Let me leave you with one of my favorite stories I use in my parenting talks.
Two girls were playing far away from their village when one of them, 10 years old, fell into a well. Her friend was a skinny 6-year-old. She tied a rope onto a bucket and lowered it into the well. She pulled and pulled with all her might. Her hands became blistered and bloody, but she never quit until her friend was out. When they returned to the village, no one believed their story. The girls insisted it was true. The old, local wise man carefully listened and proclaimed that he believed the girls. When asked why, he said it was very simple. There was no adult there to tell her she couldn’t do it.”
Tim Jordan, M.D., is a Behavioral Pediatrician who counsels girls aged grade school thru college. Listen to his weekly podcast, Raising Daughters, to gain information on raising strong, resilient girls. For more info on Dr. Jordan’s retreats, summer camps and books visit drtimjordan.com.
